OneLaser X vs xTool P2S: CO2 Laser Engraver Showdown

OneLaser, a brand new laser company based out the US, has made big waves in the industry with the launch of their OneLaser X Series Desktop CO2 Laser Engraver and the OneLaser HYDRA Series Cabinet Dual-Laser System.

However, don't let their relative "newness" put you off - their lasers have been very well received and are set to compete head-on with the industry leaders like xTool and Glowforge in the CO2 laser cutter space. Their machines are also co-manufactured with Thunder Laser and so they carry over the quality that Thunder machines are known for.

Today, we'll take a critical look at the capabilities of the OneLaser X Series and compare it to its most likely competitor, the category leading xTool P2S.

For those with a shorter attention span, here's the TL;DR:

Pros of OneLaser X vs xTool P2S:

• Superior build quality across the board, with faster engraving speeds and acceleration. Plus, US-based customer support ensures reliable assistance when you need it.
• A 3-year warranty comes standard with the OneLaser X, compared to the 1-year warranty on the xTool P2S. This demonstrates OneLaser's confidence in the durability of their machines.
• The OneLaser X offers an option to upgrade to the air-cooled CO2 RF tube laser source. This provides finer engraving details, faster speeds, and a longer lifespan compared to the CO2 glass tube in the P2S.
• Aggressive pre-sale pricing makes the OneLaser X over $1,000 cheaper than the xTool P2S ($2,995 vs. $4,199 for the CO2 glass tube option). However, this price gap may narrow once the OneLaser X returns to its standard MSRP.

Cons of OneLaser X vs xTool P2S:

• While the OneLaser X supports Lightburn software out of the box, the xTool Creative Space software that comes with the P2S has significantly improved over the years. It is now regarded as one of the most user-friendly options for laser engravers.
• As a newer company, OneLaser is still building its reputation. While their strong start is promising, it’s natural for a new product line to experience minor challenges as the company grows. That said, the 3-year warranty and US-based customer support provide added peace of mind.

Our Verdict: 

With very few reservations, if we were investing our own dollars into a new CO2 machine, the OneLaser X is where we would invest them compared to the xTool P2, for the reasons summarized above. 

Comparing Specifications: OneLaser X Series vs xTool P2

Overview of OneLaser X and xTool P2

The OneLaser X and the xTool P2 are both powerful laser cutters, each offering unique features that appeal to hobbyists and professionals. They are popular choices for anyone looking to create high-quality designs and engravings.

Key Features of OneLaser X

The OneLaser X is a versatile CO2 laser cutter with a 55W power output, designed for precision and efficiency. It has a large working area, allowing users to work on bigger projects without restrictions.

One notable feature is the advanced cooling system, which helps maintain performance during long hours of operation. The engraving machine supports various materials, including wood, acrylic, and leather.

Users appreciate the straightforward interface, making it easy to navigate settings and controls. The OneLaser X also offers multiple safety features, such as an emergency stop button and ventilation system, ensuring a safer working environment.

Key Features of xTool P2S

The xTool P2 is another impressive laser engraver, featuring a 55W CO2 laser that delivers high-quality engravings and cuts. This machine is known for its fast processing speeds, making it suitable for larger batch jobs.

It supports an extensive range of materials, including metals and composites. A standout feature is its powerful engraving capabilities, enhanced by cutting-edge technology for precision.

The xTool P2 also incorporates a user-friendly interface, allowing even beginners to create stunning results with confidence. Enhanced airflow and exhaust systems ensure that smoke and debris do not affect the quality of work, which is crucial for effective operation.

Design and Build Quality

The design and build quality of the OneLaser X and xTool P2 are essential for users interested in performance and durability. Each laser cutter machine integrates features that enhance their functionality and user experience.

Physical Build and Working Area Comparison

The OneLaser X has a robust frame designed for stability during operation. Its working area is spacious, allowing users to handle large projects comfortably. The machine features an optional riser base that elevates materials, optimizing space for taller items. In contrast, the xTool P2 offers a similar working area but emphasizes compact design. This CO2 laser engraver is suitable for smaller workshops, while still providing ample room for most tasks.

Both machines are equipped with a dual-cylinder air pump, which helps in efficiently removing smoke and debris during laser engraving. The high-performance brushless motor in both machines ensures smooth operation and minimal vibration. Users can expect precision in their projects because of these well-thought-out designs.

Durability and Material Quality

Durability is a crucial factor in choosing a laser engraving machine. The OneLaser X is built with high-quality materials, ensuring it can withstand heavy usage over time. Its metal construction provides resilience against wear and tear, making it reliable for long-term projects.

The xTool P2 also boasts impressive material quality, using durable components that reinforce its structure. The integration of high-performing parts enhances the overall longevity of the machine. Users benefit from both the P2 and OneLaser X, as both laser cutter machines offer reliable performance day after day.

Software and User Interface

The software and user interface are crucial aspects of comparing the OneLaser X and xTool P2 laser machines. Both systems offer distinct features and usability, impacting user experience and overall performance.

Software Functionality for OneLaser X

The OneLaser X is compatible with the industry standard, Lightburn laser software (not included), designed for various tasks related to laser engraving and cutting. It supports common formats like DXF, SVG, and BMP, providing flexibility for different projects.

Users can benefit from features such as batch fill, allowing for the engraving of multiple items efficiently. The software also includes helpful tutorials, making it easier for beginners to navigate its functionalities. Regular updates keep the software relevant and improve performance, ensuring the laser cutter machine meets evolving user needs.

xTool Creative Space Features

The xTool P2 laser engraver operates with the xTool Creative Space (XCS) software. This software is particularly favored for its intuitive design and compatibility with multiple file formats, including those from LightBurn software.

XCS includes advanced features like dual cameras for precise alignment and multiple attachment options, enhancing the flexibility of the CO2 laser engraver. The interface is user-friendly, making it accessible for both novices and experienced users who want to maximize their productivity.

Ease of Use and Learning Curve

When it comes to ease of use, both machines cater to different user levels. The OneLaser X Lightburn software is equipped with clear tutorials, helping new users quickly learn necessary skills. Its layout is straightforward, aiding in efficient navigation through tasks.

Conversely, the xTool P2’s XCS offers a seamless learning experience due to its well-organized interface. Users find the transition to advanced features, like batch fill, to be user-friendly. Regular software updates for both machines ensure continual improvement, making laser cutter operations smoother and more efficient for all users.

Performance and Capabilities

The performance and capabilities of the OneLaser X and xTool P2 are crucial for users looking for efficiency and quality in their projects. Key aspects such as engraving speed, cutting quality, and unique features make a significant impact on their effectiveness.

Engraving Speed and Precision

Engraving speed is vital for productivity in any laser engraving machine. The xTool P2 is noted for its impressive speed, capable of reaching up to 400 mm/s. This allows it to complete projects quickly without sacrificing quality. In contrast, the OneLaser X offers competitive speeds, designed for efficiency in various materials.

Precision is also a strong point for both machines. The OneLaser X features advanced optics, allowing for detailed work on intricate designs. The xTool P2 utilizes precise alignment systems, ensuring that the laser cuts and engraves exactly where intended. This attention to detail can significantly affect the final product's appearance.

Cutting and Engraving Quality

When it comes to cutting and engraving quality, both machines demonstrate excellent performance. The xTool P2 operates as a CO2 laser cutter, providing clean cuts on materials like wood, acrylic, and fabric. Users have reported consistent results, with minimal burn marks on edges.

The OneLaser X also excels in cutting precision, especially with thicker materials. It can process various substrates and offers advanced features for different styles of engraving. The integration of 3D modeling capabilities further enhances the xTool P2’s versatility. Its batch fill 2.0 feature allows for efficient handling of multiple items at once, making it ideal for larger projects.

Safety and Maintenance

Maintaining safety and ensuring proper upkeep are crucial for the effective operation of a laser cutter machine. Understanding the integrated safety features and maintenance requirements can help prevent accidents and prolong the machine’s lifespan.

Integrated Safety Features

Both the OneLaser X and the xTool P2 are designed with advanced safety features for users.

• Enclosed Design: The OneLaser X has a fully enclosed structure, which reduces exposure to laser light. This enclosure enhances safety during operation.
• Smoke Purifier: A built-in smoke purifier helps reduce harmful particles and gases, keeping the workspace clear.
• Exhaust Fan: The exhaust fan aids in venting away smoke and fumes, promoting better air quality in the working area.
• Water-Cooling System: Both machines incorporate a water-cooling system (for the CO2 glass tube version), which prevents overheating, thus increasing safety during extended use.

These features are vital for ensuring that the laser engraving machine operates safely without compromising user health.

Maintenance Requirements and Upkeep

Regular maintenance of the laser cutter is essential for optimal performance.

• Cleaning: Users should regularly clean the lens and mirrors to maintain cutting precision and efficiency.
• Inspecting the Exhaust System: Ensuring the exhaust fan is functioning correctly helps avoid smoke build-up and contributes to a safer workspace.
• Checking the Water-Cooling System: Regularly checking the water-cooling system prevents overheating and extends the machine’s life.
• Routine Software Updates: Updating the software ensures the laser engraving machine operates with the latest features and safety protocols.

Failing to follow these maintenance practices could lead to decreased efficiency or safety hazards. Proper attention to these details helps users get the most out of their CO2 laser cutter.

Final Thoughts and Recommendations

The OneLaser X stands out as a top-tier choice for CO2 laser engraving, offering superior build quality, faster engraving speeds, and the option to upgrade to an air-cooled CO2 RF tube for finer detail and durability. Its 3-year warranty—triple that of the xTool P2S—demonstrates OneLaser’s confidence in its product, while US-based customer support adds a layer of reassurance. Additionally, its aggressive pre-sale pricing makes it over $1,000 cheaper than the xTool P2S, offering incredible value for the money.

While the xTool P2S shines with its user-friendly Creative Space software and established reputation, the OneLaser X holds its ground with strong features and long-term potential. For those willing to bet on a promising newcomer with outstanding hardware and support, the OneLaser X emerges as the smarter investment—especially with its current pricing advantage.